film reviews by Darrell SchweitzerCopyright (c) 2007 / May not be reproduced without permission
I urge WEIRD TALES readers to see Guillermo del Toro’s
Pan’s Labyrinth (Picturehouse, 2006) — but if you are expecting a bittersweet fairy tale about a young girl who escapes the cruelty of the adult world through the discovery of a secret, magical realm, you may be in for a shock. Mr. del Toro is very close to being two directors entirely. One makes movies in English, such as
Hellboy. The other makes them in Spanish, such as
The Devil’s Backbone, one of the great ghost films. The English films are commercial and very Hollywood. The Spanish ones are more personal, art films.
Pan’s Labyrinth is the work of the director of
The Devil’s Backbone.
Once more, in Pan’s Labyrinth, we are taken to the Spain of the early Fascist era. The Civil War is ostensibly over, but Republican guerrillas continue to operate. 11-year-old Ofelia (Ivana Banquero) travels with her mother (Ariadna Gil) to a military outpost where the mother, recently widowed, is to marry (Fascist) Captain Vidal (Sergi Lopez), by whom she is pregnant. Vidal is not only every child’s nightmare of a usurper-of-mother’s-affections, but the kind of guy who gives Fascism a bad name, whether shooting innocent peasants or brutally torturing prisoners.
Ofelia has apparently found her way into Fairyland and learned that she is a lost princess from an underground realm. She must go on a quest to open the portal to her real father’s kingdom. All of this parallels the adult world. Look closely for symbolic objects: two knives, two keys, and Captain Vidal’s watch.
“Reality” moves from grim to horrific. Since Vidal has shot the only available doctor as a Republican spy, an army paramedic delivers the baby. Ofelia’s mother dies. The only person to whom Ofelia can turn for help, the housekeeper Mercedes (Maribel Verdu), is also a Republican spy, and Vidal finds out. The war closes in.
To this point, Ofelia’s quest into Fairyland has something of a Neil Gaiman sensibility, like Mirrormask only much darker, with the adult world and the child’s fairy world in conflict, one reflecting the other. Ofelia is an innocent child right on the cusp of (not-so-innocent) adolescence. When she eats a couple grapes in the Otherworld — something mythic characters must never do — she is told that the magical realm is closed to her forever. But she just as she gets a second chance, she attempts to poison Captain Vidal in order to save Mercedes. This is a justifiable act in adult terms, but does it mean that Ofelia is no longer entirely a child? Can anyone but a child resort to Fairyland magic in her moment of supreme crisis?
I’ve promised no spoilers, so let me just say that it ends in tragedy, from the failure of the child’s magical solution being applied to the brutal, adult world. The film’s bitter conclusion offers only scant, magical comfort, in which we, having grown up beyond our ability to see fairies, do not really believe.
This is a superb effort. The visual effects (beginning with an insect that turns into a fairy) are flawless. The performances are excellent. Ivana Banquero (Ofelia) is apparently 12 but fully capable of such a demanding role. Sergi Lopez as Captain Vidal is a entirely believable villain, a man obsessed with his own heroic myth. Every totalitarian regime, from Franco’s to Pol Pot’s, has needed such fanatics to actually do the dirty work.
Pan’s Labyrinth is a profound meditation on the nature and limitations of the imagination. But this is one story about a little girl and fairies that is for adults only.
* * *
Much more for kids (if anyone) is Eragon (20th century Fox, 2006), based on Christopher Paolini’s novel.
Let me try to get this straight: Darth Vader, a dragon-rider of Pern, betrays his fellow Jedi Knights, then becomes a Dark Lord (OMT). (Official Management Term. See Diana Wynne-Jones’s A Tough Guide to Fantasyland.) Although pursued relentlessly by a Ringwraith, the spunky Princess slips the last dragon egg to 17-year-old Luke Skywalker (Edward Speleers) before she is captured. Luke, living with his uncle in rustic Assendofnowhere, discovers his Destiny just as his uncle is killed by Imperial Stormtroopers. He is then guided by Aragorn/Han Solo (Jeremy Irons), learning to fight, ride the dragon, and pose heroically. Unsurprisingly (there are no surprises here), he is the sole Hope of the Land, but, adolescent twit that he is, he risks everything by breaking into the Deathstar to rescue of the Princess (remember her?)... and then the good guys triumph at Helm’s Deep, but the hero has not yet confronted the Dark Lord and we haven’t even met the bloody elves yet. Sequels loom menacingly.
This might even entertain very young audiences but anybody else can skip it. It is the bare-bones boy-becomes-hero fantasy, with no emotional cost.
* * *
I chanced to see Charlotte’s Web (Paramount), which is everything Pan’s Labyrinth is not: a sweet story about a brave little girl, her special pig, and Life’s Lessons with all the hard parts removed. You would have to have a heart of stone not to be uplifted.
But it didn’t put me off eating bacon.
Darrell Schweitzer is senior contributing editor at WEIRD TALES. The other editors do hope that he is at least eating organically raised bacon. READ THE WHOLE STORY...